Search in the blog:

2023-10-07

Pentax K 55/1.8 vs Pentax A 50/1.7

The SMC Pentax [K] 1:1.8/55 (1975) lens has its roots in the Takumar lenses.


(K 55/1.8 optical design: 6 elements in 5 groups)

It's gone in the M and A series, replaced by the SMC Pentax-M (1977) and Pentax-A (1984) 1:1.7 50 lenses.


(M/A 50/1.7 optical design : 6 elements in 5 groups)

The Pentax K 55/1.8 is sometimes considered to have a more interesting character than the Pentax M/A 50/1.7.

I have both (K 55/1.8 and A 50/1.7) lenses:



And I did some comparisons at f/1.8-f/1.7. The paired shots were taken with the Sony a7c (FF, 24MP) from the same point, but the scenes may differ slightly due to the wind.

1.

(K 55/1.8)

(A 50/1.7)

2.

(K 55/1.8)

(A 50/1.7)

3.

(K 55/1.8)

(A 50/1.7)

4.

(K 55/1.8)

(A 50/1.7)

5.

(K 55/1.8)


(A 50/1.7)


The Pentax A 50/1.7 obviously gives a wider angle of view. The Pentax K 55/1.8 gives a more contrasty image (I think it's the effect of this concrete copy of the Pentax A 50/1.7). The circles of confusion are larger with the K 55/1.8, which is to be expected due to the longer focal length. But I do not see a big difference in the character of the images.

Since I shoot with an adapter, I chose the K 55/1.8 because I like the K-series itself better than the A-series. But when shooting with a Pentax digital camera, the A-series is much more convenient, I would prefer the A 50/1.7 (that I used to shoot with Pentax DSLRs).

0 comments:

Post a Comment

Blog Archive